Ms Justice Mary Irvine expresses concern over distress caused by delays in enacting laws on phased care payments

8 year old Luke received furtherdamages from the HSE because of the actions of Mullingar General Hospital inmismanaging his birth which led to his brain damage in 2006.  Luke now suffers with dyskinetic cerebalpalsy which affects his limbs and ability to walk and talk.  Despite his physical disabilities Luke isdescribed by medical experts who examined him as a bright and engagingboy.  He now attends mainstream schooland recently came top of his class in his end of year maths test.

A High Court judge, when approving a further €580,000 payment for a young boy with cerebral palsy, has expressed concern over distress caused by continuing delays in enacting laws allowing for phased payments to meet the lifelong care needs of people who successfully sue over catastrophic injuries.

In anticipation of the legislation, Luke Miggin’s case was settled and adjourned three years ago on terms including an interim payment of €1.3 million. Further payments were later ruled, bringing the sum above €2 million and the child’s mother, Emily Miggin, returned to court again yesterday because the judge had to formally rule another payment to meet further future care costs.

Approving that payment, Ms Justice Mary Irvine said successive ministers for justice had promised the periodic payments legislation but it remained not possible to say when the legislation would be published.


There was a failure to recognise the distress caused to families because the legislation is not available yet, she said. “I will say no more than that. My frustration is evident. I apologise to you that we have not got the legislation.”

Addressing Ms Miggin, the judge noted this was the third or fourth time the case had come before the court and said she knew the distress litigation causes families with children such as Luke. “They can’t get on with their lives because of ongoing litigation.”

Ms Miggin, a therapist, had given up her work and is her eight-year-old son’s full-time carer, said she applauded the judge on what she had said about the lack of periodic payments legislation but she was satisfied with the latest settlement.

Care costs

The case will have to return to court again when sums for aids and appliances and further future care costs will have to be decided.

The child’s case arose from the circumstances of his birth at Mullingar General Hospital in February 2006. He has cerebral palsy, is in a wheelchair and requires 24-hour care.

Through his mother, Emily Miggin (46), Ballinadrimna, Athboy, Co Meath, Luke sued the HSE and consultant obstetrician Michael Gannon of Mullingar hospital alleging negligence in the circumstances of his birth. Liability was admitted by both defendants.

The Irish Times

If you have any further queries, please contact any of the following from our medical negligence group:

25 June 2014

    Gillian and all at Augustus Cullen Law, A million thanks for a great job done. Justice for our son at last!!

    Catherine, Liam & William

    Dear Michael, A great result was achieved because of your efforts and we were truly blessed to have you on our side.

    Kathleen, Medical Negligence Client

    Dear Joice…you are and have been very professional, sympathetic and dignified in all of your dealings with us and I put that down to one simple fact. You listened.

    James, Medical Negligence Client

    Geraldine, Thank you most sincerely for all your hard work and commitment to these children.

    Freda McKittrick, Head of Barnardos Beacon Guardian Ad Litem service

    Neil is an absolute gentleman to deal with – kind, tactful and very efficient. We could not praise him highly enough. He brought us through a horrible time.

    Sean, Medical Negligence Client

    Many thanks again for a job well done. We really appreciate all your hard work and practical advice.

    Corporate client in a commercial litigation matter

    Dear Jamie, You and your team in ACL were so professional, diligent and prompt. I have recommended you and the firm, and will continue to do so

    Lorraine McCarthy

    Gus Cullen and the firm’s approach to addressing the key issues was professional, yet personal, efficient yet attentive.


    The process is a difficult one and when you deal with people who are so professional and yet genuine/real people, it makes it so much easier... so thanks a million.


    Request a Callback